Abraham Lincoln Quotes


Southern men declare that their slaves are better off than hired laborers amongst us. How little they know, whereof they speak! There is no permanent class of hired laborers amongst us.


Citations

Abraham Lincoln, 1809-1865, 16th President of the United States (Republican, IL), September 17, 1859

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

This quotation is interesting for two reasons. First it is a good example of the twisted logic of some of the Slavery apologists who claimed that the Negro slave was better off than the free wage earner. The second reason is that it illustrates the norms of the treatment of the working man before the Civil War. The union movement would change the situation for the free laborer over the next century and then holidays and worker rights became normalized in American society. See {641290} for another of his absurd arguments.


This fascinating quotation is very frequently quoted out of context. For example even in modern times some Southern slavery apologists quote this passage stating that Adams saw no moral difference between slavery and employment of the lower classes. And anti-capitalists have claimed that this was an attack on capitalism as no better than slavery for many workers. Neither is true. The debate was on the head taxes that states should pay to the central government. Southerners were claiming that they should not have to pay per person taxes on slaves. Adams position was that they should pay in that there is no practical difference in the work and working conditions very often. If slaves should be exempted from the head tax, so should the poor, lower class workers like the fisherman in New England. He always maintained at huge moral difference between a poor free worker and a slave even thought their working conditions might be similar.


At the time, it did seem impossible that labor and capital would ever have harmonious relations. But the notion that slavery would solve the problem is as preposterous as anything ever entered into the American political dialogue. But there were many in the South, and some in the North, who actually believed it. Even 150 years later, while labor and capital relations were much better than pre Civil War, they still could not be described as “harmonious” or “friendly”.


This quotation was a the description of the nail manufacturing operation using slave labor on Thomas Jefferson’s plantation, Monticello. Note the almost romantic scene that the author paints of slavery and forced child labor. That is why this is a very important quotation. This biography of Jefferson, written for a young audience, was typical of material written about the South and slavery from the late 19th century till the late 20th century. The South was still resentful about losing the war, and there was still, late in the 19th century, negative feelings in the rest of the nation about the South’s lack of patriotism and worse their basic morality of having not only supported but fought to maintain the cruel, evil institution of slavery. Many wanted to get these sectional feelings behind them and move forward. One way was to do much revisionist history about the institution of slavery and the reasons for the Civil war. Books, plays, and later films, and the school curricula, were designed to edit out or minimize the brutality and cruelty of slavery. And the reasons for the Southern rebellion was not any longer only to maintain slavery, but more palatable, almost noble reasons were substituted for the reality that slavery was the only major reason for the Southern rebellion. Maintaining a different culture and way of life, freedom from Federal intrusion in state and local affairs, honor and others were then new given reasons, and the problems of Reconstruction for the South exaggerated to justify the then Jim Crow American era of legal discrimination and lynching. This passage came from a book that was so popular with young people, that it was published again in a new edition as late as 1961. Most white Americans, growing up in the 20th century learned this version of events and many vestiges of it could be seen, even in the 21st century. In the 1970s, with an end to legal segregation, attention turned to the culturally and historically distorted views, and slowly schools began to change curricula. However, in the Southern States, in order to prevent the schools from departing from the false, romantic view of Southern Slavery, local schools where not allowed to select their own textbooks and in many cases even their own library books.


Abraham Lincoln
Abraham Lincoln
  • Born: February 12, 1809
  • Died: April 15, 1865
  • Nationality: American
  • Profession: President

Abraham Lincoln was an American politician and lawyer who served as the 16th President of the United States from March 1861 until his assassination in April 1865. Lincoln led the United States through its Civil War—its bloodiest war and its greatest moral, constitutional, and political crisis. In doing so, he preserved the Union, abolished slavery, strengthened the federal government, and modernized the economy.