James G. Frazer Quotes


The heaviest calamity in English history, the breach with America, might never have occurred if George the Third had not been an honest dullard.


Citations

James G. Frazer, 1854–1941, Scottish social anthropologist, The Golden Bough, 1890

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

Some of the Patriots of Early America realized that the oppressions of British rule were coming from Parliament and initially took the position that only the King could make laws for the colonies and not Parliament. Therefore, they were as Englishmen challenging illegal English laws. Most American hostility was directed at Parliament and not the King. However, once there was any physical resistance, King George came down with such a heavy hand that American hatred transferred to him. For related quotes on the King/Parliament issue, see {639145}, {639144}, {639142}, {639141}, {639140}, & {639137}


A number of the British Parliament were opposed to using force to get America to accept British taxation and other rules. They thought the trade with America was excellent for both, and the military advantage of the combination was superior to any force on earth. To upset that over who had the right to tax and under what conditions seemed foolish. They counseled negotiations. It was thought at the time that Lord North, the Prime Minister, was perceived to be a hard liner who would not back down regarding America. This quotation describes papers that the professor found that proved that Lord North was not one of the hawks and did not want to send troops to America. However, the King was insistent as he and his hawkish advisors felt that England and the king would be weakened if the world could see America flouting the king. It was a “domino theory” of the effect on all the colonies. North wanted to resign but the king thought him the only competent man in the kingdom who could manage the government and would not allow North’s resignation. The Prime Minister, as a loyal servant of the King, executed the policy he thought unwise and used his political skill to marshal and maintain a majority for a hard line in Parliament. Apparently, he tried to resign over America on several occasions. The world would be very different place had he successfully resigned.


Some of the Patriots of Early America realized that the oppressions of British rule were coming from Parliament and initially took the position that only the King could make laws for the colonies and not Parliament. Therefore, they were as Englishmen challenging illegal English laws. Most American hostility was directed at Parliament and not the King. However, once there was any physical resistance, King George came down with such a heavy hand that American hatred transferred to him. For related quotes on the King/Parliament issue, see {639145}, {639143}, {639142}, {639141}, {639140}, & {639137}


This was one of the first and is considered the best of the Colonial writings against taxation without representation. Despite this, Dulany is not well known in American history because when the Revolution finally came he was a loyalist.


This quotation is very important because it illustrates in the first of our great national political debates, the same views held by extreme, right wing anti-government, and Tea Party adherents regarding government in general and taxation in particular. See {634235} and {634234} for more of his arguments at the Ratification Convention.


The Continental Congress told each colony should establish its own republican government quickly so that the people did not have to depend on England for anything, and that the English Monarchy be opposed and supplanted anywhere where they wanted to exercise authority.


Note that the Queen always used the 3rd person rather than the 1st when referring to herself. This was true of most of the leading public figures in England at the time. Although she detested Gladstone, she gained control of her feelings and did her duty and “sent for” him to form the Government. She was personally delighted when, as she predicted, his government then had political difficulties.


Americans were by no means united in wanting to take up arms against Britain. Relatively few of the loyalist quotations have come down to us, but here is one. It also illustrates why some Americans wanted complete independence: So that they could escape their debts to English merchants. Most however had more noble and unselfish motives. As a matter of fact, the American Revolution is unusual in the sense that there were so many men of substance who sacrificed much of their material wealth for the American ideal. There were also the rogues and opportunists as Galloway describes.


Actually, Queen Elisabeth II, at that time the Queen of England, was very sophisticated about the policies of the nation. Chomsky’s point was not that the Queen was ignorant; it was that her role is ceremonial and it is not critical or even material that the monarch in a Constitutional Democracy understands or approves of the government program that is being presented.


While the official battles of the American Revolution did not begin until 1776, parts of the American colonies were in a de facto state of rebellion and the British could not enforce their laws. See {636925} for another of the King’s statements.


Fox was one of the opposition leaders who were opposed to the heavy handed policies that the British King and Government had used.


This quotation is interesting for two reasons. First, this is one of the most severe criticisms of a cabinet and ministers in English history. The second reason of interest is that it was these same ministers who made the policies and the decisions that would bring on the American Revolution. Were it not for the incompetence, there might not be a United States today. Pitt’s son later also castigated the ministers. See {641503}.


See {641497} for a quote from the Grenville speech. Fox, a conservative on most issues was an absolute radical on the issue of America. To aggravate the hawks in parliament, he used to dress in the colors of George Washington’s uniform to show his support once the war broke out.


Some of the Patriots of Early America realized that the oppressions of British rule were coming from Parliament and initially took the position that only the King could make laws for the colonies and not Parliament. Therefore, they were as Englishmen challenging illegal English laws. Most American hostility was directed at Parliament and not the King. However, once there was any physical resistance, King George came down with such a heavy hand that American hatred transferred to him. For related quotes on the King/Parliament issue, see {639145}, {639144}, {639143}, {639141}, {639140}, & {639137}


James G. Frazer
James G. Frazer
  • Born: January 1, 1854
  • Died: May 7, 1941
  • Nationality: British
  • Profession: Scientist

Sir James George Frazer OM FRS FRSE FBA was a Scottish social anthropologist and folklorist influential in the early stages of the modern studies of mythology and comparative religion. His most famous work, The Golden Bough (1890), documents and details the similarities among magical and religious beliefs around the world. Frazer posited that human belief progressed through three stages: primitive magic, replaced by religion, in turn replaced by science.