James Barron Quotes


I must contend that the liberty and perhaps the lives of so many valuable & estimable Americans ought not to be sacrificed to points of honor, taken in the abstract.


Context

Opponents claimed that it would be dishonorable to negotiate with terrorist states and to pay ransom at any time. This tension between principle and empathy with American prisoners first emerged in the Barbary Wars, but has been with America ever since. Our policy position of honor vis a vis terrorists has been the same since then. We do not negotiate. However, exceptions have been made many times in American history, as it was here thanks to military leaders like Barron. This was the origin of the military tradition of never leaving Americans behind in when they have been captured in conflicts that was so contentious such as the Afghanistan and Iraq Wars.


Citations

James Barron, 1768-1851, Naval Commodore, Reply to other Americans who were opposed to paying a ransom for American sailors who have been taken by the Barbary States and were being held in terrible conditions, Quoted in Joseph Wheelan, Jefferson’s War

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Linked Quotes

While to Madison the principle that “war is better than tribute” was “settled policy”, there were many who disagreed. See {640867} as an example.


Related Quotes
James Barron
James Barron
  • Born: September 15, 1768
  • Died: April 21, 1851
  • Nationality:
  • Profession:

James Barron was an officer in the United States Navy. He served in the Quasi-War and the Barbary Wars, during which he commanded a number of famous ships, including USS Essex and USS President. As commander of the frigate USS Chesapeake, he was court-martialed for his actions during the Chesapeake–Leopard affair in 1807 which led to the surrender of his ship to the British. After criticism from some fellow officers, the resulting controversy led Barron to a duel with Stephen Decatur, one of the officers who presided over his court-martial. Suspended from command, he pursued commercial interests in Europe during the War of 1812. Barron finished his naval career on shore duty, becoming the Navy's senior officer in 1839.