Regulatory Failure Quotes



Whitmore uncovered massive company underreporting of injury on the forms that were required by Federal law and OSHA regulations. The George W. Bush administration position had been that industrial accidents were much reduced citing the reports which the companies had systematically underreported. Whitmore who was in charge of the OSHA records confirmed the underreporting to the House Committee on Education and Labor. His agency, OSHA, tried to keep him from testifying, but he did so as a private citizen. He was then placed on ‘administrative leave’ and had no access to any OSHA records thereafter. This was an unusual time in American history, and this atypical administration censored government scientists and repeatedly refused to be truthful in Congressional Hearings. It was so bad that the Attorney General resigned in large part over his testimony to Congress.


Regulation had been adopted to make sure that certain products were made to standards and appropriate quality. A small fee was taken by the regulator to attest to the quality and place a seal on it. However, the system degenerated into a system where one had to pay the fee and everything passed inspection without regard for quality. Child was one of the first observers of the criticality of implementation of regulatory schemes and the danger that a regulatory system was vulnerable to corruption.