Direct Election Quotes



This Pinkney view prevailed in the original Constitution, but this practice was reversed by the 17th Amendment of 1913. The source for this statement is the notes of Alexander Hamilton.


In the Israeli system, voters do not vote for individual politicians; they vote for parties. Based on the proportion of votes, the parties are apportioned the number of seats in the Knesset they get. Then each party selects their winning candidates from their full list of candidates in order. The voters do get to see the entire list for each party, and there are party primaries to determine who is on the list and in what order.


Prior to this amendment U. S. Senators were usually elected, not be the people of a state, but by the State Legislators. This amendment provided for the direct election of Senators. This dramatically changed the role of the Senator who before had to be responsive to the political leaders of his state. With the passage of this amendment, Senators had to be responsive to the general population of the entire state and not just the state legislature.