Harvey Brooks Quotes
The scientist is speaking in a forum to which opposing scientific views are not more or less automatically accorded equal access. The politician is free to select his own experts to develop an issue in the way that has maximum political utility to him. Truth may be only incidental. the scientist is speaking in a forum to which opposing scientific views are not more or less automatically accorded equal access. The politician is free to select his own experts to develop an issue in the way that has maximum political utility to him. Truth may be only incidental.
One classic example is the scientist who is testifying before a Congressional Committee. Typically if there is a political issue, the politician of each viewpoint will find a scientists who supports their view. In a huge country, they can always find on or two to support any idea regardless of its validity. In the world of science, the scientist who has been doing experiments in a field for years and has published articles in peer-reviewed journals, teaches other scientists who do outstanding work, and have won prizes or accolades from his/her peers is given much more credibility than the scientist who has none of these accomplishments and just may have a different point of view and claim that the first scientist is in error UNLESS the critical scientist can show mathematical or other scientific proof that the first is wrong. Often in politics, the lesser critical scientist offers questions which the leading scientist cannot answer bit in science that proves nothing. There is ALWAYS much more a scientists does NOT know about an area than he does know. See {623513}.
Harvey Brooks, 1915-2004, President's Science Advisory Committee (3 Presidents), President, American Academy of Arts and Sciences, Director of the Science, Technology, and Public Policy Program, Harvard University, Comment on the Scientist who is interacting with a politician or politicians, "Expertise and politics: problems and tensions”, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 119, 1975
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
Actually during this period, automation and other forms of technological unemployment have been far more responsible for the loss of good jobs in America than offshoring which has been far more responsible than competition from immigrants.
In the world of science, today’s truths are all modified or placed into a more sophisticated concept tomorrow, If there is evidence that supplants old science, it is immediately discarded by the good scientists. Politicians hold on to debunked political and economic ideas regardless of the evidence. Einstein superseded Newton’s view of physics of the universe and gravity, and quantum mechanics has shown that Relativity was somewhat oversimplified and did not apply to the very small world inside atoms. The only reason Aristotle was right for a few hundred years because the Dark Ages virtually stopped the development of science. Politicians who want surety from scientist are frustrated in that the good scientists know that it can never be given without caveats. Meanwhile politicians are sure of their positions and state them with certainty despite the fact that there is usually NO evidence for them that a scientist would ever accept and if there were in a few years it would be found to be oversimplified or wrong. See {624499} .
The administration at the time was notorious for ignoring science in making policy decisions – especially of the results were in disagreement with Christian religious fundamentalist positions.
Their cultures, training and education are totally different, but most important their missions are intrinsically different. The security experts have failed if there is a single serious fatal accident or public exposure to a toxic or dangerous substance. The scientists know that they only way to eliminate all risk is to eliminate scientific research.
- Born: August 5, 1915
- Died: May 28, 2004
- Nationality: American
- Profession:
Harvey Brooks was an American physicist, "a pioneer in incorporating science into public policy", notable for helping to shape national science policies and who served on science advisory committees in the administrations of Presidents Dwight D. Eisenhower, John F. Kennedy, and Lyndon B. Johnson. Brooks was also notable for his contributions to the fundamental theory of semiconductors and the band structure of metals. Brooks was dean of the Division of Engineering and Applied Sciences of the Harvard University.