Orrin Hatch Quotes
Scorecards are common in the political process, but they are inappropriate in the judicial process. The most important tools in the judicial confirmation process are not litmus paper and a calculator.
Hatch, Orrin. "Statement of Hon. Orrin G. Hatch." Confirmation Hearing on the Nomination of John G. Roberts, Jr. to be Chief Justice of the United States, U.S. Government Printing Office, 2005, p. 16.
See Abraham Lincoln for a similar view.
In America, the best attorneys have stayed in private practice where they could make much more money than government service or become professors and scholars of law. In either case, most have a track record that would make Senate confirmation difficult even if they wanted to be Federal Judges. A few like Abraham Lincoln went into politics. The Supreme Court is somewhat of an exception because of the power it wields, but even then many great attorneys have not been so inclined. Federal judges have usually been above average as attorneys, but not among the greatest.
The Republican leadership wanted him to hasten to file a political corruption case before election day so that a Republican Congresswoman, in a tight fight, could criticize her opponent, the state attorney general, for being soft on corruption. Inglesias would not disclose the confidential information regarding his investigation to his Republican colleagues. Shortly thereafter he was fired and there was no reason given nor was there any record of inadequate performance. When the Congress investigated the case, the Republican Attorney General could not give a reason that he fired Inglesias.
Judges are restrained by the law and precedence (stare decisis), as well as having to uphold what he/she thinks are undesirable laws or find against laws he thinks are good. He must decide on the law and the facts of the particular case. And if he is an appellate or a Supreme Court judge he must make compromises to accommodate other justices hearing the case along with him/her.
From time to time, the assessment of a prospective Supreme Court justice has depended on an attempt to move the court in a particular direction or to prevent that. This is as opposed to the issue of the competence of the nominee. In most cases, such nominees may not have been the best qualified but they have been extremely competent. In a few cases, such as that of Justice Clarence Thomas, the justice was mediocre and inexperienced at best, but his virtues were his race and his total ideological consistency. Most attorneys can predict his vote in advance. He has never asked a question in oral arguments. See {623452} .
Orrin Grant Hatch is an American attorney, retired politician, and composer who served as a United States Senator from Utah for 42 years (1977–2019). He is the longest-serving Republican U.S. Senator in history and the longest-serving U.S. Senator from Utah.