Marvin Ammori Quotes


In 'Bush v. Gore,' five justices had a partisan outcome in mind and then made up the judicial principle to justify it, while claiming that the decision would not be precedent for any future cases.


Citations

Ammori, Marvin. "The Supreme Court's Partisan Decisions." Slate, The Slate Group, 2012.

Related Quotes

The New Deal liberal Democrats had complained that the Supreme Court was making national policy and law and not interpreting law. They tried to pack the Supreme Court by adding more justices who would be more sympathetic to the New Deal. (See {587549}.) At the beginning of the 21st century it was the conservative Republicans who were making the same claim that the Supreme Court was making law and not interpreting it. The pattern seems to be when the court votes for your side, they are interpreting the law. When they vote for the other side, they are activist—making law improperly.


In general, Justice Jackson was correct. Almost all major Supreme Court decisions that have ruled against the Legislative Branch or the Executive Branch, have been, reversed by a future Supreme Court, reversed by new legislation, reversed by a subsequent Constitutional Amendment, reversed by science or technology, or acknowledged by future generations to be wrong but were now moot and needed no correcting. The greatest of the Supreme Court decisions have generally been those that upheld the Congress and the Executive.


Two openings appeared on the Supreme Court for Nixon to fill. He heard from many people on recommendations, but he wanted to fill the posts with “strict constructionists.” Rehnquist had written giving him a political operational definition of a strict constructionist. This memo was never released to the public by the White House on the grounds that it was protected by Executive Privilege. However, the definition given had virtually nothing to do with the concept of strict construction but is a definition of a ideological conservative constructing his own meaning to the Constitution. The source for the text came from John Dean, the Counsel to the President, who found this memo in his White House file and revealed it at a question and answer session at the Commonwealth Club of San Francisco, October 10, 2001.


At the time, there was a very sharply divided Supreme Court with the majority consisting of very conservative justices who did not follow the principle of Stare Decisus and had overturned a number of previous Supreme Court opinions with which their ideology was in conflict.


This kind of attack on the Supreme Court by a prominent legal figure is quite unusual. However, the appointment of the ideologue, Clarence Thomas and his effect on the balance of the court triggered much controversy.


Marvin Ammori
Marvin Ammori
  • Born:
  • Nationality: American
  • Profession: Lawyer

Marvin Ammori is a lawyer, civil liberties advocate, and scholar best known for his work on network neutrality and Internet freedom issues. He currently serves as Chief Legal Officer of Uniswap.