George Catlin Quotes
I have, for many years past, contemplated the noble races of red men who are now spread over these trackless forests and boundless prairies, melting away at the approach of civilization.
Catlin, George. Letters and Notes on the Manners, Customs, and Condition of the North American Indians. Vol. 1, Published by the author, 1841, p. 2.
Justification for policy of settling all Indians west of the Mississippi River.
This quotation is often used as the greatest evidence the white usurpation of Indian land and the dubious value of all the treaties that had been made with the Indians guaranteeing them specific lands. Jackson, however, was not completely accurate. The Iroquois who fought on the American side in the Revolution were still on their lands in New York State. However, the Iriquois had their dealings with the State and local governments, and fared better than those tribes that depended in the Federal Government—especially with racists like Jackson in the Presidency.
Most of her modern admirers tend to repress this quotation which is very embarrassing for most modern conservatives. However, there is a minority of thinkers who maintain that land, unused, is open to anyone who will make use of it to improve civilization. Many conservationists, in contrast, extol unused land for preservation.
This is an important quotations for two reasons. First, one of the white Europan myths in the colonial era was that the Native America had not concept of land ownership and title. This quotation clearly refutes that/ Second, this shows that some Europeans coming to the new world opposed the view that the white Christians and a moral right to the Native American “heathen” land. A few like Williams did not.
Carson was one of the few Indian Agents who spent every penny of his budget on the Indians as opposed to himself. He was married to an Indian woman and was close enough to many Indians that he understood their resentment whenever they came into a town. They were treated terribly and while most of them were literally starving, seeing the white opulence produced resentment.
This quotation is the most hypocritical statements made by any President in his Inaugural Address. Jackson would not only flip flop on this principle and force the Indians (Cherokee and the Trail of Tears) to remove from their traditional lands in the East, but the Federal Government by Treaty was obligated to guarantee the sovereignty of the Cherokee land. What even made Jackson’s actions worse, was that the Cherokee had won their case before the Supreme Court, and Jackson became the only President in American history to refuse to enforce a Supreme Court decision that the Cherokee were entitled to their traditional land.
George Catlin was an American lawyer, painter, author, and traveler, who specialized in portraits of Native Americans in the Old West.