George Crook Quotes


[Describing Indian warriors:] ... a match for any man.


Context

Crook had a deep respect for the Indians. The Native Americans in turn trusted their enemy in an usual mutual respect. See Red Cloud {46587}


Citations

George Crook, 1828-1890, Cavalry General and the Leading Indian Fighter, Quoted in Utley, Frontier Regulars: The United States Army and the Indian, 1973

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

A part of this quotation is very often taken out of context by just quoting the phrase “prosecution of an exterminating war” implying that Lamar was urging genocide. However, the war was urged only if the Indians did not cease their raids and massacres. Further, he specifically excludes women and children from the “extinction”. In addition he holds out the option of forced “total expulsion” if the raids continue. Brutal his threats were. And given that the whites were taking the Indians traditional lands it is easy to see where there were reasons for Indian resistance to white expansion. However, there was another reason that Lamar and most of the white settlers wanted the Indians expelled: They wanted the land.


Earlier in his life, the President had very racist views towards the American Indian as can be seen in {588991}. However, in his regiment he organized—the Rough Riders—for the Spanish American War, there were a number of Native Americans who acquitted themselves with distinction and Roosevelt had a change of mind and heart. Further he was somewhat older and had time to reflect on the irrationality of his earlier view.


Most of the American Indian Tribes did not practice slavery. These two were very large tribe exceptions. There were also some tribes which would capture a prisoner and maintain them by coercion, but typically these captives could be adopted and have the same rights and freedoms and obligations as other tribe members. The Cherokee and Comanche practiced the Southern white style of chattel slavery.


At the time, Jefferson was the Governor of Virginia and the Indians and white settlers in the Western part of the state were coming into increasing conflict. This rather heartless and blood thirsty quotation of Jefferson’s surprises many of his great admirers. Especially because of his historical sophisticated and empathetic way he treated Indians. See {589102}, {589103}, {589113}, {589125}, and {605068}. Jefferson saw Indians much like he saw whites—differentially. Some were friends, some neutral, and some dangerous enemies. His wish to exterminate or ethnically cleanse these Indians was limited to these Indians—not to Indians in general. Nonetheless, it shows a violent side of Jefferson that was in play with enemies. As President, he was aggressive against the Muslim Pirates (see {623707} and {617123}).


In March of 1814 Jackson led a force to track down the Red Sticks. When they did so at Horseshoe Bend. Jackson made a frontal assault on the Red Stick Breastworks which might have gone badly had not a cotangent of Cherokee Indians—also concerned about the Red Sticks attack on their settlements, assaulted the Red Sticks from the rear. The Red Sticks, caught between the two uncoordinated attackers, lost over 900 men and the battle which then decided the war. In this Battle, Junaluska, a Cherokee, saved Jackson’s life. Years later he would not differentiate between the different Indian peoples and contrary to a Supreme Court order, forced the Cherokee from their settled farms and ranches and moved them to the Oklahoma Territory.


The whites had constantly encroached on the Cherokee land which was too large for any reasonable patrolling by the Indians themselves. The Federal government persuaded the Cherokee to sign a treaty by which the Indians would give up their title to the larger part of their land. The most important quid pro quo was that the Federal Government would protect the remainder of the Cherokee land from incursion by whites or even other Indians. However, whites who coveted the land started to encroach and build farms and ranches. The Federal government was reluctant to use American soldiers against American citizens and was looking for a way out. However, the Cherokee chiefs were reminding them of their obligation. The state governments were less concerned about Federal treaties, and Georgia passed a law that said that all the Cherokee land must be governed by State Law contrary to the Treaty which gave the Cherokee total sovereignty. But the Feds were not anxious to have a showdown with the states on this issue. Whites, with the connivance of the state governments and the support of some Federal Officials offered to amend the treaty with the Cherokee. The whites would pay the Indians fair market value for their land in the East. The Federal Government would provide equal amount of land in the Indian Territory of Oklahoma, then a territory. The Feds would assist with the relocation and provide troops to protect the Cherokee from thieves and raiders—whites and Indians, and would guarantee that the Cherokee would be completely sovereign in the new land. The chief’s did not want to renegotiate the old treaty—they just wanted it enforced. The Supreme Court ruled in their favor, but President Jackson, ignored the ruling and forced the Cherokee onto the Trail of Tears for Oklahoma and the whites took over the valuable Cherokee land.


George Crook
George Crook
  • Born: September 8, 1828
  • Died: March 21, 1890
  • Nationality: American
  • Profession: Soldier

George R. Crook was a career United States Army officer, most noted for his distinguished service during the American Civil War and the Indian Wars. During the 1880s, the Apache nicknamed Crook Nantan Lupan, which means "Chief Wolf."