Edmund Morgan Quotes
The preoccupation of American historical and literary scholars with the New England Puritans must seem to outsiders like an obsession.
Morgan, Edmund S. The Genuine Article: A Historian Looks at Early America. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2004.
The colony created out of a political dispute with the Massachusetts Bay Colony, was created when in June of 1636, Hooker and his entire congregation, driving their cattle and carting their belongings, left Massachusetts and set out for the Connecticut Valley, founding Hartford and a new colony. The following year the constitution was written and ratified. It was in many ways similar to the Massachusetts legal system except that it was written and could not easily be changed. However, there were two important historical innovations. First, while Massachusetts had limited voting rights to members in good standing of the Puritan Church, The Fundamental Orders provided for separation of church and state and allowed others (males only) to vote as well. See {624151}. The other innovation was that this appears to be the first introduction of term limits in America. It limited the Governor to a single term, unlike Massachusetts where Governor Winthrop was a fixture.
This is a quotation which shows that Christmas was not a Christian Holiday that was commonly celebrated In early America. The reason that this is important is when there were many legal battles of public schools and municipalities celebrating Christmas and exhibiting crèches and Christmas trees, several of the proponents argued the doctrine of originalism—namely that we should not declare unconstitutional anything that was common and accepted at the time of the Constitution’s writing, debating, and ratification. They argued that the First Amendment was not intended to cover celebrations of Christmas as the founding fathers would not have made unconstitutional that which was common. While the principle of originalism has advocates and critics, the originalism theory does not hold regarding Christmas because Christmas was not commonly celebrated in early America. In no state was Christmas a holiday, and there were jurisdictions that had actually outlawed the celebration of Christmas which was associated with Catholics and not all of them. See {629843} for another.
Edmund Sears Morgan was an American historian, an eminent authority on early American history. He was Emeritus Professor of History at Yale University, where he taught from 1955 to 1986. He specialized in American colonial history, with some attention to English history. Thomas S. Kidd says he was noted for his incisive writing style, "simply one of the best academic prose stylists America has ever produced." He covered many topics, including Puritanism, political ideas, the American Revolution, slavery, historiography, family life, and numerous notables such as Benjamin Franklin.