Ignatius Valentine Chirol Quotes


The brotherhood of Islam undoubtedly provides a strong bond of sentiment between all Mohammedans from the northwest shores of Africa to the Great Wall of China and the remote Philippines, but, from the time when the first Arab Caliphates fell out, it has never yet prevented bitter feuds and sanguinary wars between rival Mohammedan states.


Citations

Ignatius Valentine Chirol, 1852–1929, British Historian, Journalist & Diplomat, “Islam and Britain”, Foreign Affairs, March 1923

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

While it may be true that some major powers do not presently want unity between Muslims, the Sunni-Shiite conflict has been ongoing for centuries—long before many “major powers” even existed. It is the oldest, continual civil war in history. It is certainly true that major Islamic powers like Saudi Arabia oppose unity was Saudi Arabia is a Sunni majority country and regard the Shiites as not only blasphemous and evil, but see them as dangerous.


Most Muslims when asked what they are will say “A Muslim” whereas most members of every other religion will give his/her nationality first and his/her occupation or profession second. Very few answer with their religion.


To make matters worse for the Muslims, the tiny foreign entity in their midst—populated by "heathens who do not follow the command of God"—have created a much higher standard of living for their people, improved the land and its productivity in ways that have been far superior to traditional Islamic methods, reclaimed much of the desert that the Muslims could not, and produced a military that has staved off the hostilities of all of Islam, and has done all this without any oil or other natural resources to sell. Israel is a living counter-example to the superiority of Islam and its traditions which is so important to Muslims.


This quotation is often given by those who believe that nothing has really changed regarding the Arabs and non-Islamic Westerners in the last century. While the support of dictators, Israel and support for that democracy, the artificial Western imposed borders, 9-11, or the Iraq war is often cited as the cause of Arab hostility and murderous aggression, as this quotation demonstrates, the problems and attitudes and behaviors existed long before any of these occurred. The borders were not set until after WWI and all the other causes occurred almost 50 years later, Yet there was still the propensity for fanaticism and violence. Sikes actually was one of those who was to determine the Arab borders, making one of the first “suggested” maps of the area for the English.


What is particularly interesting about this passage is that a Middle Eastern contemporary historian and commentator compared circumstances to political events with the Umayyads and the Abbisids to those in Persia and Rome. Chosroes (Khosrow) was a Persian King who had his brothers murdered, and Caesar was viewed as a tyrant. Even then, the history of politics, in one country influenced events and attitudes in others,


Ever since the world dominance by the Judeo-Christian West, any military of physical victory of Muslims over Christians was considered symbolically very important by Islamic leaders.


There is of course no way to tell the sect of a Muslim by physique alone, although there are major behavioral differences. The reason the quotation was newsworthy was that it was amazing that a senior Senate leader was so ignorant of such a critical and problematical subset of the world.


His views are a mix of modernism and fundamentalism. He favors democracy and elections but also favored the Taliban destroying the great ancient Buddha statues when he was called an idol worshipper for urging the preservation of art.


What is ironic about this fact is that 1000 years ago, the Muslim Middle East was scientifically and mathematically far in advance of Europe. However, after about 1100 AD, the Muslim religion began to lose its intellectual tolerance and cultural appreciation for science and innovation to the point where innovation of any kind was regarded as heresy, and the logic and empiricism that was present in early Islam disappeared, and there has been little scientific innovation and progress in traditional Arab Islamic nations ever since.


From a religious point of view a Christian or Jew was cursed, but ibn Naghrela had the respect of most (See {623787} ) and was the most influential citizen of a Golden Era of Muslim Spain. In 1056 he was assassinated by jealous Muslims.


This is an example of the politicization of history. Late in the first millinium Islamic warriors invaded and conquered much of Hindu India. The Muguls controlled much of India for hundreds of years. When the English conquered India, the Muslims rejected Western education and legal systems while the Hindus did not. After several generations the Hindus, better educated, and more sophisticated in Western ways took advantage of the numerical majority and regained control under the British. With Independence, Islamic nationalists insisted upon partition of the country creating a Muslim country, Pakistan. Millions of Indians were murdered in internecine attacks during the partition. Subsequently, Muslim historians have written one version of the history of India, while Hindu historians have written another. They appear to come from different planets or parallel universes. British historians have a third universe.


The Caliph in the past was the religious and secular leader of all Muslims. Many of the fundamentalist terrorists have as their objective, the reestablishment of the Caliphate which will unite all Islamic countries under one leader who is both the secular and religious supreme authority—a religious and a civil dictatorship. Most Muslims, like most people of all religions, are not terrorists and believe that much of terrorist activity violates many basic tenets of Islam. However, in order to function, the terrorist must have the tacit support of sufficient numbers of people so that they can function without being exposed. That is an important objective for Al-Qaeda: to enlist sufficient numbers of ordinary people who although they will not commit the terrorist acts, will support the objectives of the terrorists and provide money, shelter, and other services.


Ignatius Valentine Chirol
Ignatius Valentine Chirol
  • Born: May 28, 1852
  • Died: October 22, 1929
  • Nationality: British
  • Profession: Historian, Journalist Diplomat

Sir Ignatius Valentine Chirol was a British journalist, prolific author, historian and diplomat.