Lyman Abbott Quotes
Society exempts woman from police functions. She is not called to be sheriff or constable or night watchman. She bears no truncheon and wears no revolver. She answers not to the summons when peace officers call for the posse comitatus. She is not received into the National Guard when bloody riot fills the city with peril and alarms. Why not? Is she not the equal of man? Is she not as loyal? as law abiding ? as patriotic? as brave? Surely. All of these is she. But it is not her function to protect the state when foreign foes attack it; it is the function of the state to protect her. It is not her function to protect the persons and property of the community against riot; it is man's function to protect her. Here at least the functional difference between the sexes is too plain to be denied, doubted, or ignored. Here at least no man or woman from the claims of equality of character jumps to the illogical conclusion that there is an identity of function.
Without realizing it Abbott conceded some of the reasons that some people opposed women serving in the military. His entire argument hangs on the slender thread that it is not the function of a woman which was a view held by some people with particular religious and philosophical views. When that group was clearly shown to be a minority of Americans, women entered military service and joined police forces across the country.
Lyman Abbott, 1835–1922, Congregationalist theologian, editor, and author, “Why Women Do Not Want The Suffrage”, The Atlantic Monthly, September 1903
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
This illustrates some of the illogic of some of the opponents of female suffrage. The fear was so great, that the very thought of woman voting along with men becomes in his mind, women controlling the electoral process. Since women voted in America sometimes they have made the difference in an election and sometimes it was the men—most often it was neither as a bloc. Also, it never occurred to Abbot that women could possibly enforce the laws along with men or fight in the military if the voters decide on war. See {629405} for his rigid view. A logical fallacy of Abbot’s argument is that the same thing can be said of old men. If the decisions of the voters need enforcement or military action, the older men of the society will not be the ones to enforce the laws or fight in the wars. So according to Abbot’s defective logic, the older (or disabled) men should not be allowed to vote when they reach the stage in life that they can no longer fight in war or serve as a policeman.
She is vehemently opposed to allowing women to serve in the armed forces.
She added a floor amendment which included sex as a prohibited form of discrimination in the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
This was a quarter of a century before women in the United States could vote.
SNCC had been formed to promote equality, but race and class were the issues, not gender. Many of the women left SNCC and proceeded separately to start a women’s movement.
This relatively radical viewpoint regarding equal rights for women was expressed by Roosevelt as his Senior thesis at Harvard in 1880. In those days, the kind of scrutiny of everything a candidate ever wrote or said that is characteristic of modern politics, did not exist. It is very doubtful that if the Republican Party officials had ever known that he had espoused these views—even as a young student, that he ever would have risen so high in the party, much less get nominated at the Vice Presidential candidate which was his entree to the Presidency. When in office however, there is no record of him reviving his youthful proposal that women who marry retain their maiden names.
Prevented by the Military from ever taking office
Given the time, this was an amazing demand. Fuller preceded all the more famous American feminists and was an inspiration to them.
The Act allowed women and other workers who were the victims of wage discrimination to sue the discriminating employers even after the statute of limitations and run out provided that they victim had no knowledge of the discrimination. Lilly Ledbetter was a Goodyear Supervisor who was for years paid far less than the male supervisors doing the same work. But the company kept it secret and Ms. Ledbetter didn’t find out until the statute of limitations had said she could no longer sue. The Lilly Ledbetter Act corrected that injustice. President Obama observed that discrimination in pay affects not only the woman or other worker, but also the entire family which might therefor not be able to obtain health care, education, or care for elderly parents. At the time that this quotation was made, white women in America who were working full time were earning only 77 percent of what men earned. For minority women, the proportion is even less. As bad as that was, it was an improvement over the situation when the equal pay act was passed 50 years before. Then, women earned only 53 percent of what a man did.
She was the First Lady, who in many ways was also one of the nation’s leading feminists. Betty Ford, Barbara Bush, and Hillary Clinton were also First Ladies who supported key feminist position but ER was 30 years ahead of them—a time when conservatives and sexists viewed her as a dangerous radical. For example, see {585211}.
At the time and for the next decade she was one of the few world leaders who made women’s equality and rights a major priority. But slowly American and European women and many men began to give higher priority to using foreign policy and foreign aid. Then women from Asia and Africa began to take up the issue and in the early 21st century even some women in the Islamic nations began to fight for women’s rights. Mrs. Roosevelt. However, was the first modern major and high visibility politician to make women’s rights a major international and national issue.
The law at that time gave a married woman almost no rights. The husband legally controlled the family assets regardless of who had earned or provided them. He aslo had absolute control of the upbringing of the children. Women could not vote and in many states were considered property of the husband.
Abbot was apparently ignorant of the American women who did fight in the American Revolution, the War of 1812 or the Civil War where there were a few women who fought on both sides some of whom were decorated. Nor did he seem to acknowledge Joan of Arc and other female warriors in world history. But he would be truly shocked by the tens of thousands of “civilized” women who volunteered and served in the American military once they were allowed to do so and the “civilized” men who fought with them as compatriots.
During the Civil War, the government produced paper money for the first time. The clerks in the Treasury had to cut the printed money to size and separate the several bills on a sheet. However, with more work and men needed for the war effort, Spinner came up with the good idea of using women as Treasury Department Clerks. Chase, one of Lincoln’s rivals for the Presidency, was the Secretary of the Treasury and although not enthused allowed Spinner to allow some women into the Federal Workforce. See {629786} for one reaction.
Jorge Mario Bergoglio
- Born: December 18, 1835
- Died: October 22, 1922
- Nationality: American
- Profession: Theologian, Pastor (Protestant), Editor, Author