Stephen Breyer Quotes
Rarely in the history of law have so few undone so much, so quickly.
The decision was 5-4 and reversed a trend in which the court had been going before appointments by George W. Bush tilted the majority. See {614910} for a quotation from the majority opinion.
Stephen Breyer, U.S. Supreme Court Justice, Majority Opinion on School Desegregation, June 28, 2007
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
The decision was 5-4 and reversed a trend in which the court had been going before. Roberts and another appointment by George W. Bush tilted the majority. See {614911} for a quotation from the 4 justice dissent.
The case was Shelley v. Kraemer where the Supreme Court outlawed discriminatory restrictive covenants A restrictive covenant was a condition that was written into the deed on a piece of property. Even if the owner of the home did not want to discriminate, the previous owners who wrote the restrictive covenant into the deed (or his relatives and heirs) could sue and invalidate the sale. In many cases, insurance would not sell title insurance or banks would not give mortgages for a Black or a Jew where there was a covenant in the deed, even if the covenant was more than 100 years old. Homeowner associations would also enforce the covenants which were originally written into all the deeds of the development. Once the supreme court ruled that restrictive covenants were unconstitutional, no court would enforce any of these lawsuits. It was one of the fastest steps forward in the history of Civil Rights since the day after the court decision racists could no longer enforce the covenants that were in tens of millions of deeds in America.
Smith, an extreme racist, was so rabid that MacGregor was supporting the Civil Rights Bill, he followed him off the House floor to make this statement. MacGregor jokingly told Smith that he was wrong. He had 17 Negroes in his District.
He maintained these policies even after President Eisenhower’s January 1954 speech calling for people who were displaced as the result of urban renewal projects to be provided with Federal assistance in housing regardless of race. It is not known whether Sherman Adams shared Cole’s position with the President. Adams himself was forced to resign in a corruption scandal.
This painting depicted a young black girl walking to school surrounded by 4 U. S. Marshalls protecting her from the crowd of white racists trying to prevent her from attending an elementary school under court order. The vicious race hatred that school integration revealed was the national problem that was then surfacing. The graphic is the illustration that appeared in Look with that name.
This quotation distressed many ultra rightists who otherwise were avid followers of Mises. See {632407} for another quotation that distressed many European conservative devotees of Mises.
What made this quotation very dramatic was that the state of Virginia, under the previous administration dominated by religious fundamentalists had passed a law banning same sex marriage. Several private Virginia citizens had sued the State in Federal Court, asserting that their Constitutional rights were violated by the ban. The Attorney general normally defends the state in any court proceeding. However, Herring agreed with the plaintiffs on the case, that the Virginia law was unconstitutional, so he and the State entered the case on the side of the plaintiffs and against the state law. His reference to the right side of history was related to the fact that as late as 1964 Virginia had a law prohibiting interracial marriage which they enforced and the Supreme Court invalidated. Thus, on marriage, Virginia had a track record of being on the wrong side of history and the law.
Fiji has extensive internal strife between the native Fiji Islanders and the Indians who the British colonists brought to Fiji as laborers. The former are culturally and politically very traditional and tribal; the latter are more democratic, global and professional.
Wilder was the first Black Governor of Virginia. Deval Patrick, the first Black Governor of Massachusetts.
The recent FBI directors have had a difficult legacy to cope with. In the 1930s throughs the 1960s, the FBI (under J. Edgar Hoover), worked very closely with Southern, Racist, Law enforcement agencies who were constantly covering up and often participating in assaults and lynching of Blacks. Hoover, despite the fact that he was a closet gay, projected a very masculine FBI image and would not have female agents. Even in the Civil Rights movement local FBI offices were working closely with Southern law enforcement to suppress the Civil Rights demonstrations. Nationally, the FBI was not only illegally surveilling Martin Luther King, but Hoover who despised King actually had agents try and blackmail him and pressure him into committing suicide. So the legacy was not good for hiring women of Blacks and Jews, Hispanics, Asians and other minorities as well. Even when Comey made this statement, he was dealing with a group of highly conservative and racist FBI agents who were illegally leaking information that would help to swing the Presidential election to Donald Trump, who was opposed by most women and almost all blacks. So Comey had to persuade new recruits to enter the Bureau despite the legacy and existing component that would not be very comfortable for them. At the same time, the educational qualifications for the FBI were very high (unlike most local and stat law enforcement agencies). Most people who could meet them, could easily qualify for other jobs that paid more than the FBI so it took a good bit of desire and commitment to get anyone to join.
It was indeed the first government that was ever founded on that fallacious principle. In retrospect, it was amazing that more Southerners did not question why no other government in the history of the world based a society on that principle. The Southern hubris was a great failing for them.
American socialists and communists were very vocal about the terrible racial discrimination that existed in the United States until the Civil Rights and Voting Rights Acts were passed in the 1960s. In 1933 describing Black African societies as anything but primitive was rare regardless of the historical facts. When communists and socialists too these anti-racist positions, the racist Southerners then conflated this position and accused all opponents of segregation of being socialists and communists. This tactic actually worked quite well and for many years discouraged many politicians or others from speaking out against discrimination lest they be accused of being a communist or socialist.
There are few people today who could believe that a United States senator would castigate the head of a Federal Agency for spreading “racial equality propaganda.” But at the time—1943—the actions of Education Commissioner John W. Studebaker and his Assistant took remarkable courage.
Incredibly enough, until this Supreme Court Decision, bigots would sell a home on the open market and write into the deed that the house may never be sold to a Black, a Jew, a Mormon, or any other person one of the owners did not like. This was actually enforced by American courts trying to preserve segregation in housing until 1948 and the 1956 decision stopped the practice but housing segregation persisted by other means.
In the razor thin 2000 Presidential election the Republican controlled Florida legislator called a special session to name their own electors to go to the electoral college. The Governor, Jeb Bush, was the brother of the Republican candidate.
- Born: August 15, 1938
- Nationality: American
- Profession: Judge
Stephen Gerald Breyer is an American lawyer, jurist, and legal scholar who is serving as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. He was nominated by President Bill Clinton on May 17, 1994, and has served since August 3, 1994.