Lawrence M. Krauss Quotes


If we wish to convince countries like Iran that the development of nuclear weapons is not in their best interest, we need to demonstrate that maintaining or enhancing our own arsenal is not in our interest.


Context

Many politicians and military thinkers disagree with Kraus. America, England, France, Russia, and Israel have all demonstrated over the years that even with great provocation they would not resort to nuclear retaliation nor have they ever threatened use of WMDs. Iran, in contrast, has repeatedly stated as one of their major objective, the total destruction of another UN member state—Israel. Further, Iran has never possessed a weapon that it did not use shortly after possession, including poison gas. Therefore America and the United Nations have all determined that a double standard is necessary with Iran.


Citations

Lawrence M. Krauss, Theoretical Physicist, “Letting Go Of Our Nukes”, New York Times, July 7, 2012

Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations

Related Quotes

This was his last publication. He died of a heart attack as the magazine was being printed. Since this was written one other possible use of nuclear weapons has been suggested—namely, retaliation for a biological attack. From a policy point of view, maintaining an arsenal of biological weapons for retaliatory purposes is dangerous and use for retaliation of biological weapons is not very controllable and arguably less humane than a nuclear weapon. His point however still holds. We have to have a national defense policy against many threats and we have to have defense policies that handle all these without nuclear tactics is insufficient to handle any of the threats without causing more problems and we have other weapons and techniques that are just as, if not more, effective. They and systems under development have the major role in our current defense policy.


The alternative deterrent was to maintain an army of over 2 million men overseas in both Europe and Asia, and the cost was much greater than the then perceived cost of nuclear weapons. At the time no one figured the cost of coping with the radioactive material and waste as well as the cleanup of nuclear bomb factories like Hanford. These costs were still not known byt the 21st century.


The origin of the United States refusal to rule first use out lies with the Cold War concern of a massive Russian Ground attack in European countries. Even with NATO, we could not deploy ground and air resources fast enough to prevent the takeover of entire countries. Then when we amassed the troops and airpower to counterattack, there would be massive civilian casualties of the invaded nations. So American strategy, at the insistence of our European Allies was to deter invasion. By renouncing first use, the Western Powers would almost invite the Russians to invade European nations. There was a similar fear of North Korea and China,


Lawrence M. Krauss
Lawrence M. Krauss
  • Born: May 27, 1954
  • Nationality: American, Canadian
  • Profession: Physicist

Lawrence Maxwell Krauss is an American-Canadian theoretical physicist and cosmologist who previously taught at Arizona State University, Yale University, and Case Western Reserve University. He founded ASU's Origins Project, now called ASU Interplanetary Initiative, to investigate fundamental questions about the universe and served as the project's director.