Stephen Carter Quotes
I say disallegiance rather than disobedience to emphasize the distinction between breaking the law—disobedience—and rejecting the sovereign’s claim to sovereignty—disallegiance …. We need disobedience and we should not be so quick to assume that disobedience is the same as disallegiance.
Stephen Carter, Attorney, Professor and Columnist, Dissent of the Governed, William E. Massey Sr. Lectures, Harvard University, 1995
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
Writing about congressional investigations such as those carried out by the House Un-American Activities Committee:
Gets was commenting on the Apple Computer Company who refused to obey a court order to create a program that would break into any iPhone. Apple thought the court order was not only bad public policy, but was not legal, so they refused and appealed to start the legal process. However, the FBI which had claimed that they had no other way to view some critical investigative data, found one, and not wanting the case to go to higher courts where they might or might not lose, the dropped the case, thus stopping the legal appeal as in the United States courts will hot hear theoretical cases as they will in some countries. Since apple was not in danger of being held in criminal contempt any longer the could not longer appeal.
Stephen Lisle Carter is an American law professor at Yale University, legal- and social-policy writer, columnist, and best-selling novelist.