David Kay Quotes
By absenting the United States from the process by which international legal rules are made, the Senate has denied the country’s ability to shape them.
Because the Senate has not ratified some international treaties, the United States does not participate in some international efforts to create international rules and law. The reason for non-ratification is generally given as potential loss of American sovereignty. At the same time, we spend billions of dollars trying to influence and shape the world along free market, democratic lines, and then are not able to participate in some of the most important forums where we could do just that. It is a constant dilemma and the Senate goes both ways depending on its mood, public opinion at the time and the political composition of the Senate. See {637031} and {637032}.
David Kay, Legal Scholar, U.S. State Department Official, Director of UCLA’s International Human Rights Program, “U. S. Foreign Policy Without Treaties—Or The Senate”, Foreign Affairs, September – October 2013
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
The Constitution was not drafted until 1787 and was ratified later. In the interim the young United States functioned under the Articles of Confederation, in a sense, our first Constitution. This clause established that the Federal Government should have the exclusive power and authority to conduct foreign affairs.
The Congressman was being critical of the George W. Bush Administration and their tendency to decide which leaders and countries were legitimate and moral and which were not, and then invading the “bad” and executing the leaders as with Iraq and Saddam Hussein.
This quotation is an excellent example of a kind of political statement that sounds terrific at first, but when you think about it, it is hard to determine what it means. It is clearly some kind of criticism of international and multinational organizations but it is impossible to know what the candidate is proposing. He does not urge that the US not participate in the multilateral organizations? He warns that when we do participate, we should not cede our moral authority to them. But no one can determine had a sovereign nation like the United State cedes any moral or other kind of authority by participating in these organizations.
The notion of Executive Privilege developed over the years. Our first President thought nothing of giving the Senate access to all the papers and records regarding the negotiations of the treaty with Great Britain.
Individual countries are bound only by the treaties and compacts that they have signed and ratified. So very often someone will allege that a country has violated international law, but that nation may not have signed the Treaty or Compact that binds them, so thy may not be in violation at all whereas some other country in similar circumstances would be. Also, many countries (including the United States) sign treaties but take exception to some of the provisions. Then there are not bound by that provision. This is what makes International Law so complicated and difficult to understand.
- Born:
- Nationality: American
- Profession: Scientist
David A. Kay (born c. 1940) is a weapons expert, political commentator, and senior fellow at the Potomac Institute for Policy Studies. He is best known for his time as United Nations Chief Weapons Inspector following the first Gulf War and for leading of the Iraq Survey Group's search for weapons of mass destruction following the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Upon presentation of the Group's finding that there had been significant errors in pre-war intelligence concerning Iraq's weapons programs, Kay resigned. The ensuing controversy served as impetus for the formation of the Iraq Intelligence Commission.