James Harvey Robinson Quotes
We have denounced the stupidities of the British censors and lamented the cutting off of our supply of German newspapers, even of scientific periodicals; and why, we asked, need any one get so heated by the words of a gentle philosopher like Bertrand Russell? And, now that we are actually in the war, these same things which we deprecated in the policy of European countries have become our policy.
America was entering the First World War as a combatant but there was considerable anti-war sentiment. The Wilson administration over-reacted and instituted many repressive laws and regulations. Leading Americans like Eugene Debs was jailed for several years simply for opposing the war and the military conscription that went with it. Our scientists were not allowed to receive German scientific journals which of course hurt us and not the Germans who read their research and ours.
James Harvey Robinson, 1863–1936, Historian & Co-Founder of the New School for Social Research, “The Threatened Eclipse of Free Speech”, The Atlantic Monthly, December 1917
Sourced by: Eigen's Political and Historical Quotations
In WWI Congress had passed a law that prohibited anyone from undermining or interfering with the war effort. The defendants had passed out anti-war literature to young men heading for military service. The court then overlooked the First Amendment and came up with a strange logic where the “clear and present danger” was the test of whether the First Amendment would apply. The anti war pamphleteers went to jail. Today, we look back on this and find it very surprising but this is yet another example of erosion of freedom and civil liberties when the nation is at war. By the 1950s, the Supreme Court had reversed itself and the First Amendment was restored to its original intent.
The Justice Department shut the magazine down under the Espionage Act {612703} This censorship in hindsight was clearly unconstitutional, but this is yet another example of civil rights being eroded in wartime with timidity on the parts of the courts to uphold the constitution when the Executive is stating that the court ruling could greatly harm the nation. In retrospect, such testimony has almost always been fabricated lies or paranoid fears.
We were in the midst of WWI.
Note how the second paragraph nullifies the first of the government declares an emergency. This is a trick that is very common in constitutions.
The Chinese government has strict censorship of its internet. The U.S. State Department has developed software to bipass the Chinese censorship. The purpose of this is to guarantee freedom of speech on the internet. However, the Chinese see an ulterior motive.
James Harvey Robinson was an American historian, who co-founded New History, which greatly broadened the scope of historical scholarship in relation to the social sciences. Jay Green concludes: