John Ruskin Quotes
Large fortunes are all founded either on the occupation of land, or lending or the taxation of labor.
Ruskin, John. Fors Clavigera. Vol. 1, George Allen, 1871.
Ironically, Fitzhugh who detested socialism, held this basic socialist principle. His solution however, was that the profits were necessary for society, and therefore slavery was the solution for Blacks AND whites.
In most countries, most of the rich people have inherited their wealth. America, with its very low inheritance taxes, produces many rich people who inherit their wealth, but there is so much opportunity even more people are able to create their own fortunes. Both sets of rich people constitute a very small proportion of the American population.
The socialist extremists wanted the state to own all the major businesses which would be operated without a profit allowing more money to be paid to the workers without any price increase for the consumer. Yet, many of them wanted the innovation and other virtues of the private sector and few were ready to take on the political chaos that would be involved in eliminating private ownership of businesses. Crosland forced them to logically accept the concept of profits as desirable for the society.
Mises defines government revenue in such a manner that it always relly belonged to individuals, therefore when government invests in enterprises that accumulate capital via profits, Mises does not consider it capital accumulation. One counterexample of this point is the George Washington Bridge in New York, built in Mises lifetime by Robert Moses of the New York Port Authority. The tolls on the bridge paid off the bondholders who financed much of the initial construction. But then capital started to accumulate at such a rapid rate that Moses was able to build other capital projects ranging from highways to the World Trade Center Buildings with capital constantly accumulated. The New York Port Authority under Moses generated more capital appreciation than any corporation that had been in existence at that point. And he could not even sell stock. However, the Port Authority and a few others were exceptions. Generally government did was unable to accumulate capital in its enterprises.
This is a an interesting political and historical quotation because it shows how left and right gets redefined in each age. Here we have a quotation of two sentences. By 21st century American definitions, the first statement would line Say up with the Right Wing. The second clause of the second sentence could have been written by an extreme Marxist and would be Left Wing. Definitions and norms change and individuals even change their positions as they have more experience and reflect more on their views.
The percentage changes over time, but in a capitalistic system, capital (wealth) can be invested and generates wealth.
John Ruskin was the leading English art critic of the Victorian era, as well as an art patron, draughtsman, watercolourist, philosopher, prominent social thinker and philanthropist. He wrote on subjects as varied as geology, architecture, myth, ornithology, literature, education, botany and political economy.